Pet Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

There are 19 pet friendly hotels in Shelter Island. Need help to decide where to stay with your dog? You can browse the results below and filter by amenities to find the perfect spot. All pet policy information is guaranteed and there are no booking fees!

Pet Friendly Old Buck Run
Old Buck Run Pet Policy This 3-bedroom bungalow in Shelter Island is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request. Visit Website
Shelter Island Pet Policy This 4-bedroom house in Shelter Islandis pet friendly! Dogs of any size are allowed for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request, but all pets must be approved in advance. Visit Website
Shelter Island Airbnb Rentals Pet Policy Pet policies are determined by the individual host of each Airbnb property. For more information on the pet fee, weight limit, and other restrictions at a particular property in Shelter Island, please contact the host directly or read the House Rules section at the bottom of their listing. Visit Website
4/3 House with Swimming Pool Pet Policy This 4-bedroom house in Shelter Island is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request. Visit Website
Technicolor Paradise Pet Policy This 4-bedroom house in Shelter Island is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request. Visit Website
Shelter Island Beauty Pet Policy This 5-bedroom house in Shelter Island is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Shelter Island Farmhouse with Pool Pet Policy This farm in Shelter Island allows 2 dogs of any size for an additional fee of $100 per pet, per stay. Cats are also welcome, but all pets must be approved in advance. Sorry, no Pit Bulls. Please include details about your dog and a photo with your booking request. Visit Website
Shelter Island - Heated Outdoor Pool Pet Policy This 4-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows 2 dogs of any size for an additional fee of $100 per pet, per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
1 Gazon Road Pet Policy This 4-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows dogs of any size for an additional fee of $100 per pet, per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
3/2 Contemporary Walk to Beach Pet Policy This 3-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows dogs of any size for an additional fee of $275 per pet, per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
VRBO Shelter Island Pet Policy Pet policies are determined by the individual owner of each Vrbo property. For more information on the pet fee, weight limit and other restrictions at a dog-friendly Vrbo in Shelter Island, please contact the owner directly or read the 'House Rules' section of their listing. Also be sure to include your pet(s) in the 'Guest' field when making your reservation, so the pet fee can be included. If applicable, it will be usually be displayed in the 'On-site Fees' or 'Owner Fees' sections during checkout. Some owners will also wait until you arrive in Shelter Island to collect the pet fee. Visit Website
4/3 House with Fenced Yard Pet Policy This 4-bedroom house in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 50 lbs for an additional fee of $50 per night, plus a $250 refundable deposit. Cats and additional dogs may be allowed by request, but pets must be non-shedding and approved in advance. Visit Website
Shelter Island Hidden Waterfront Gem Pet Policy This 3-bedroom house in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 50 lbs for an additional fee of $450 per stay. Cats are also welcome. Visit Website
Sleek 3BR/5BA Home Near Nature Preserve Pet Policy This 3-bedroom house in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 50 lbs for an additional fee of $450 per stay. Cats are also welcome. Visit Website
Paradise Found on Shelter Island Pet Policy This 3-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 40 lbs for an additional fee of $150 per stay. Sorry, no cats. Pets must be approved in advance and are not allowed on the furniture or in the swimming pool. Visit Website
Mid-Island 5BR Retreat Pet Policy This 5-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 20 lbs for an additional fee of $300 per stay. All pets must be approved in advance. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Tranquility Base Pet Policy This 4-bedroom house in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 20 lbs for an additional fee of $450 per stay. Only hypoallergenic dogs are accepted. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Shelter Island Cottage Pet Policy This 5-bedroom house in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 50 lbs for an additional fee of $50 per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Waterfront Shelter Island Pet Policy This 4-bedroom house in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 50 lbs for an additional fee of $175 per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
American Beech Pet Policy This 1-bedroom hotel room in Greenport is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request. Visit Website
Shelter Island, NY, US