Every booking in August supports Best Friends Animal Society.
1 of 59

Shelter Island House

Shelter Island House welcomes two dogs up to 50 lbs for an additional fee of $150 per pet, per stay. Only rooms #10 and #11 are pet friendly. Guests with pets must call (877) 411-3436 prior to booking to verify availability of a pet-friendly room or risk not being able to check in with a pet and/or incurring any associated cancellation penalties. Well-behaved dogs may be left unattended. A dog pillow and waste bags are provided. There is a grassy area for pet relief on the property, and the nearby beach is pet friendly. Sorry, cats are not permitted.
Or, browse all pet friendly hotels in Shelter Island Heights if you’re still looking.

Room Types
Please Select a Room

    • 1 queen bed
    • Up to 2 people
    • Pet fee additional
    • 2 queen beds
    • Up to 4 people
    • Pet fee additional
    • 1 king bed and 1 double sofa bed
    • Up to 4 people
    • Pet fee additional
    • 1 king bed
    • Up to 2 people
    • Pet fee additional
    • 1 king bed, 1 queen bed and 2 twin beds
    • Up to 6 people
    • Pet fee additional
OUR GUARANTEE: Book a room now! Our canine concierge will make sure you’re assigned a pet-friendly room, so there aren’t any surprises at check-in.


Shelter Island House combines style, distinction, and historic architecture to provide guests with an authentic East End experience. Discover casual sophistication and a chance to explore the local feel without sacrificing luxury and top quality service. This property features 11 spacious guest rooms with spa bathrooms, local art, and all the amenities the modern traveler require. Awaken each morning to a complimentary continental breakfast and enjoy free Wi-Fi throughout the property. Relax by our guest pool, play a game on our Petanque courts, or visit our outstanding on-site guest bakery, restaurant or bar.


  • Television
  • Pet Friendly
  • Internet Available
  • Free WiFi
  • Meeting Rooms
  • Air Conditioning
  • Restaurant
  • Room Service
  • Breakfast Available
  • Free Breakfast
  • Parking Available
  • Free Parking
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Non-Smoking Property
  • Picnic Tables


BringFido Guest Rating
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Shelter Island House has received a rating of 4.5 out of 5 by 99 guests on TripAdvisor.

    Post a Review

    Traveler Photos

    We haven‘t received any photos of Shelter Island House yet.

    Want to feature your creature? Upload a photo of your pet at Shelter Island House! You can also share by using the hashtag #bringfido on FacebookTwitter or Instagram.

    Add a Photo

    Book with Confidence

    • This hotel’s pet policy has been confirmed by our editors and your reservations will be backed by our no-hassle .
    • Our Canine Concierge will make sure you’re assigned to a pet friendly room, so there won’t be any unpleasant surprises at check-in.
    • And you’re getting a great low rate too! We never charge a booking fee on top of the special negotiated nightly rate.
    Shelter Island House