1 of 1

American Pie Pizza & Ice Cream

American Pie offers hand-tossed New York style pizza, homemade ice cream, and covered patio seating that is dog friendly. Menu includes specialty pizza, hot sub sandwiches, calzone, chicken tenders, salads, and a wide selection of ice cream flavors. Visit Website

Or call (252) 441-3332 for more information.


BringFido Guest Rating

American Pie Pizza & Ice Cream has received a rating of 5.0 out of 5 bones by 6 canine critics on BringFido.

  • Caitlin
    Apr. 18, 2021
    Great food!

    Their food was great! We really enjoyed the outdoor seating area, though we chose to sit at one of the tables outside of the fenced in area. All outdoor seating is dog friendly. We didn't try the ice cream yet, but will definitely be back for that.

  • Desiree
    Aug. 6, 2020
    Absolutely delicious food!

    My boyfriend and I returned here multiple times during our stay. Both the pizza and ice cream were phenomenal. When I did bring my dog there was no issues on the outdoor patio.

  • Emily
    May. 22, 2019
    Best Ice Cream In OBX

    We love American Pie! It’s our favorite ice cream spot on the OBX!!!

  • Hannah
    May. 21, 2019
    Delicious Pizza AND ice Cream!

    This place was so so good. We got a medium pizza and split it between 3 adults. The medium was plenty, and allowed us to have room for homemade ice cream! The staff was SO friendly and we enjoyed talking with them. Definitely recommend this place! The patio is dog friendly, so you can bring your dog along and get them a scoop of vanilla ice cream (Max loved his)!

  • Tammy
    More than a year ago
    Nice, casual place!

    Shaded outdoor seating area and a delicious Margherita Pizza!

  • Kathy
    More than a year ago
    Yummy Pizza

    Who doesn't like pizza? American Pie offers a covered patio separated from the building. Nice railing all the way around keeps your dog contained and the roof overhead kept us in the shade. Perfect place for a pizza dinner.

Post a Review

Traveler Photos

We dug up 4 pictures of dogs at American Pie Pizza & Ice Cream.

Want to feature your creature? Upload a photo of your pet at American Pie Pizza & Ice Cream! You can also share by using the hashtag #bringfido on FacebookTwitter or Instagram.

Add a Photo
American Pie Pizza & Ice Cream