My Sugar Pie is a beloved local bakery that specializes in tasty pies and pie treats. The shop offers two dog-friendly tables outside so Fido can tag along for a pie break. Some of their flavors include peach praline, Dutch rhubarb pie, lemon meringue, and butterscotch cream. The bakery also serves tarts, cookies, and the hard to find Hoosier Pie. My Sugar Pie also ships all over the continental United States so you can get one after you've gone home. Shop hours are Monday through Thursday from 10am to 6pm and Saturday from 7am to 3pm.