Pet Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

There are 15 pet friendly hotels in Shelter Island. Need help to decide where to stay with your dog? You can browse the results below and filter by amenities to find the perfect spot. All pet policy information is guaranteed and there are no booking fees!

Pet Friendly Shelter Island Airbnb Rentals
Shelter Island Airbnb Rentals Pet Policy Pet policies are determined by the individual host of each Airbnb property. For more information on the pet fee, weight limit, and other restrictions at a particular property in Shelter Island, please contact the host directly or read the House Rules section at the bottom of their listing. Visit Website
Shelter Island Pet Policy This 4-bedroom house in Shelter Island is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are allowed for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request, but all pets must be approved in advance. Visit Website
Old Buck Run Pet Policy This 3-bedroom bungalow in Shelter Island is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request. Visit Website
Stylish Country 4-Bedroom Retreat Pet Policy This 4-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request. Visit Website
4/3 House with Swimming Pool Pet Policy This 4-bedroom house in Shelter Island is pet friendly! Dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Cats may also be allowed by request. Visit Website
Shelter Island Beauty Pet Policy This 5-bedroom house in Shelter Island is dog friendly! Dogs of any size are allowed for no additional fee. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
1 Gazon Road Pet Policy This 4-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows dogs of any size for an additional fee of $100 per pet, per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Shelter Island - Heated Outdoor Pool Pet Policy This 4-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows 2 dogs of any size for an additional fee of $100 per pet, per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Paradise Found on Shelter Island Pet Policy This 3-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows dogs of any size for an additional fee of $150 per pet, per stay. Cats may also be allowed, but all pets must be approved in advance. Pets are not allowed on the furniture or in the swimming pool. Visit Website
3/2 Contemporary Walk to Beach Pet Policy This 3-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows dogs of any size for an additional fee of $275 per pet, per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Shelter Island Hidden Waterfront Gem Pet Policy This 3-bedroom house in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 50 lbs for an additional fee of $450 per stay. Cats are also welcome. Visit Website
VRBO Shelter Island Pet Policy Pet policies are determined by the individual owner of each Vrbo property. For more information on the pet fee, weight limit and other restrictions at a dog-friendly Vrbo in Shelter Island, please contact the owner directly or read the 'House Rules' section of their listing. Also be sure to include your pet(s) in the 'Guest' field when making your reservation, so the pet fee can be included. If applicable, it will be usually be displayed in the 'On-site Fees' or 'Owner Fees' sections during checkout. Some owners will also wait until you arrive in Shelter Island to collect the pet fee. Visit Website
Shelter Island Cottage Pet Policy This 5-bedroom house in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 50 lbs for an additional fee of $50 per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Mid-Island 5BR Retreat Pet Policy This 5-bedroom vacation rental in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 20 lbs for an additional fee of $300 per stay. All pets must be approved in advance. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Gorgeous 2/2 Garage Apartment with Parking Pet Policy This 2-bedroom apartment in Shelter Island allows 1 dog under 20 lbs for an additional fee of $50 per stay. Sorry, no cats. Visit Website
Bowen's by the Bays Pet Policy Bowen's by the Bays welcomes two pets of any size for an additional fee of $20 per pet, per night. Additional pets may be accepted with prior hotel management approval. However, only the cottages are pet friendly. Both dogs and cats are allowed, and well-behaved pets may be left unattended in the room. Treats are available at the front desk, and there is a grassy area with a waste station on the property for pet relief. See Details
434 on Main Pet Policy 434 on Main is pet friendly! One dog of any size is welcome for no additional fee. Well-behaved dogs may be left unattended in rooms. Treats, bowls, towels and cleanup bags are available. There is a large grassy area on the property for pet relief. Sorry, no cats. See Details
Southampton Inn Pet Policy Southampton Inn welcomes two pets of any size for an additional fee of $55 per pet, per night. Both dogs and cats are permitted, but pets may not be left unattended in guest rooms. Treats are available at the front desk and bowls are available upon request. There is a designated pet relief area on the south side of the building. See Details
Deacon Timothy Pratt Bed & Breakfast Pet Policy Deacon Timothy Pratt B And B is pet friendly! Two dogs of any size are welcome for no additional fee. However, dogs are only permitted in two designated rooms. Guests with pets must call (877) 411-3436 prior to booking to verify availability of a pet-friendly room or risk not being able to check in with a pet and/or incurring any associated cancellation penalties. Dogs may not be left in rooms unattended. The hotel offers pet sitting and pet walking services for an additional fee. There are grassy pet relief areas on the property, and waste bags are provided at the front desk. Sorry, cats are not permitted. See Details
Old Lyme Airbnb Rentals Pet Policy Pet policies are determined by the individual host of each Airbnb property. For more information on the pet fee, weight limit, and other restrictions at a particular property in Old Lyme, please contact the host directly or read the House Rules section at the bottom of their listing. Visit Website
Hampton Bays Airbnb Rentals Pet Policy Pet policies are determined by the individual host of each Airbnb property. For more information on the pet fee, weight limit, and other restrictions at a particular property in Hampton Bays, please contact the host directly or read the House Rules section at the bottom of their listing. Visit Website
Southold Airbnb Rentals Pet Policy Pet policies are determined by the individual host of each Airbnb property. For more information on the pet fee, weight limit, and other restrictions at a particular property in Southold, please contact the host directly or read the House Rules section at the bottom of their listing. Visit Website
Water Mill Airbnb Rentals Pet Policy Pet policies are determined by the individual host of each Airbnb property. For more information on the pet fee, weight limit, and other restrictions at a particular property in Water Mill, please contact the host directly or read the House Rules section at the bottom of their listing. Visit Website
The Maidstone Pet Policy The Maidstone is pet friendly! Two pets of any size are welcome for no additional fee. Guests with pets are assigned to rooms on lower floors. Well-behaved pets may be left unattended in guest rooms if a cell phone number is provided at the front desk. Waste bags and small bowls are available and there is a Woof Menu for pups to order from. See Details